1. What are marine geoengineering techniques?
Marine geoengineering refers to the deliberate intervention in the marine environment to manipulate natural processes, which may have adverse effects on the environment or human health, particularly when these effects have a wider impact, are long-lasting, or severe. Marine geoengineering (mGE) encompasses two groups of methods. First, there are methods designed to actively remove carbon dioxide (CO2) from the atmosphere and store it long-term (known as Carbon Dioxide Removal, CDR; in the marine context, mCDR). The goal of mCDR techniques is not to reduce future CO2 emissions but to remove and store CO2 that has already been released. Secondly, marine geoengineering also includes approaches aimed at influencing the Earth’s radiation balance (Solar Radiation Management; SRM). Both are intended to help limit global temperature rise.
The ocean plays a special role in this context. As the largest natural CO₂ sink, the ocean has already absorbed about 25% of total anthropogenic CO₂ emissions. Marine carbon dioxide removal (mCDR) approaches seek to harness this capacity in a targeted manner by technically mimicking or enhancing biological or chemical processes in the ocean. Examples range from adding nutrients (ocean fertilization) to pumping nutrient-rich deep water to the ocean surface (artificial upwelling) to increasing alkalinity (raising the alkalinity of seawater by adding minerals). A detailed description of the individual methods is provided under “2. What are the different marine geoengineering techniques?”.
Differentiation from Nature-based Solutions
Marine geoengineering techniques have to be distinguished from Nature-based Solutions (NbS). Nature-based Solutions include measures that protect, sustainably manage, or restore natural or modified ecosystems. Nature-based Solutions can make an important contribution to carbon removal while also supporting marine conservation and protection goals, as well as the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Like other climate protection measures, Nature-based Solutions require appropriate framework conditions and oversight to ensure their sustainable implementation.
Differentiation from Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS)
Carbon capture and storage (CCS) and marine geoengineering both aim, in certain cases, to reduce the CO₂ concentration in the atmosphere in the long term, but differ in their approaches.
Carbon capture and storage (CCS) is a technology for capturing carbon dioxide (CO₂) and storing it underground. It can help reduce CO₂ emissions from residual fossil fuel emissions into the atmosphere or store CO₂ removed from the atmosphere - indirectly through biomass or directly through certain processes. The CO₂ to be captured can therefore come from various sources, such as industrial facilities, energy production from biomass, waste-to-energy plants, or even directly from the atmosphere. Despite technical advances, there are ongoing discussions regarding the long-term effectiveness, stability, and capacity of geological storage formations, potential environmental risks, and public acceptance of large-scale carbon capture and storage (CCS) projects (storing over 1 million metric tons of CO2 per year). In Germany, plans are currently underway to inject CO₂ into suitable storage structures beneath the seafloor of the North Sea and store it there permanently.
Marine geoengineering techniques, on the other hand, actively intervene in natural oceanic processes to enhance the ocean’s carbon uptake. Like CCS, in which CO₂ is derived from biomass or has been captured directly from the atmosphere using specific processes, mCDR methods aim to reduce the CO₂ content in the atmosphere in the long term. Most of these methods are still in the research stage and raise extensive environmental, technical, and legal questions.